droga dura y problema musical

[albertus]

pues he empezado a estudiar un libro que se llama "Thesaurus of scales and melodic patterns" de Víctor Slonimsky.
ya con la primera página he encontrado bastante diversión y os lo voy a pasar por si os queréis romper la cabeza un rato. es un puzzle-pasatiempo por llamarlo de alguna manera.

se trata de encontrar cuatro triadas que contengan los doce semitonos sin repetir ninguno. se pueden usar acordes mayores, menores, disminuidos y aumentados.
os voy a dar una pista para encontrar una solución: se puede hacer con dos acordes mayores y dos menores.

yo he encontrado cinco soluciones:

[+] soluciones

-DOS MAYORES Y DOS MENORES:
C D Abm Bbm
C Gb Dm Abm

-CUATRO AUMENTADOS
C+ Db+ D+ Eb+

-DOS DISMINUIDOS, UN MAYOR, UN MENOR
Cº Fº A G-

-TRES DISMINUIDOS Y UN AUMENTADO
Cº Eº Abº Db+

si queréis poner vuestras soluciones, por favor usad el [spoiler=][/spoiler]
para que funcione tenéis que poner un título entre comillas después de [ spoiler= "TÍTULO"]

ahora mismo estoy estudiando la forma de usar esto y ya he encontrado alguna forma de aplicarlo musicalmente. en breve haré un vídeo explicando lo que haya descubierto

[contrabajo]

Tengo ese libro y confieso que me sobrepasó un poco, está en la lista de cosas a estudiar a fondo.

Respecto al problema, con lápiz y papel en poco rato se hace, pero me lo voy a poner como reto para que lo haga un programa, a ver si me sale

[contrabajo]

Pues me he escrito un programita que los calcula por mí. Ahí van unos cuantos ejemplos.

[+] Ejemplo1

[['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'], ['F', 'A', 'C#'], ['B', 'D', 'F#'], ['C', 'E', 'G#']]

[+] Ejemplo2

[['Gb', 'Bb', 'D'], ['C', 'E', 'G'], ['A', 'C#', 'F'], ['Ab', 'Cb', 'Eb']]

[+] Ejemplo3

[['E', 'G', 'Bb'], ['A', 'C', 'Eb'], ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'], ['B', 'D', 'F#']]

[+] Ejemplo4

[['C', 'E', 'G#'], ['D', 'F#', 'A'], ['B', 'D#', 'G'], ['Bb', 'Db', 'F']]

Por cierto, mi programa tiene un problema con las enarmonías (Por ejemplo, la tríada de Ab menor me la calcula como Lab, Si, Re#; siendo lo correcto Lab, Dob, Eb. En los ejemplos lo he corregido.

Por cierto, ¿en qué página mencionan el problema?
Nicolas_Slonimsky.pdf

[contrabajo]

Me acabo de dar cuenta que el problema tiene cuatro soluciones triviales...

[+] Soluciones triviales

Cuatro cuatríadas aumentadas seguidas cubren las 12 notas:
Ej: C+ , Db+, D+, Eb+
C, E, G#
Db, F, A
D, F#, A#
Eb, G, B

Ej: Gb+, G+, Ab+, A+
Gb, Bb, D
G, B, D#
Ab, C, E
A, C#, E# (E# es enarmónico de F)

[Cerio]

Pues me he escrito un programita que los calcula por mí. Ahí van unos cuantos ejemplos.

[+] Ejemplo1

[['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'], ['F', 'A', 'C#'], ['B', 'D', 'F#'], ['C', 'E', 'G#']]

[+] Ejemplo2

[['Gb', 'Bb', 'D'], ['C', 'E', 'G'], ['A', 'C#', 'F'], ['Ab', 'Cb', 'Eb']]

[+] Ejemplo3

[['E', 'G', 'Bb'], ['A', 'C', 'Eb'], ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'], ['B', 'D', 'F#']]

[+] Ejemplo4

[['C', 'E', 'G#'], ['D', 'F#', 'A'], ['B', 'D#', 'G'], ['Bb', 'Db', 'F']]

Por cierto, mi programa tiene un problema con las enarmonías (Por ejemplo, la tríada de Ab menor me la calcula como Lab, Si, Re#; siendo lo correcto Lab, Dob, Eb. En los ejemplos lo he corregido.

Por cierto, ¿en qué página mencionan el problema?
Nicolas_Slonimsky.pdf

Qué envidia me dais los que sabéis programar, cabroneeee

[ankbass]

Pues me he escrito un programita que los calcula por mí.

Qué envidia me dais los que sabéis programar, cabroneeee

Programar es fácil, lo jodido es pensar toda esa maldita lógica y tener claros los conceptos armónicos...

[ankbass]

además lo habrá hecho en PHP... tampoco se le puede llamar programar a eso... XDDD

[contrabajo]

además lo habrá hecho en PHP... tampoco se le puede llamar programar a eso... XDDD

Con PHP me gano parte del sueldo, pero para programar de verdad no lo uso

Es Python guarro (me he puesto a programarlo en la pausa de la comida, le daría mil vueltas más): https://pastebin.com/Dur1Yizs

[+] 250 soluciones

En realidad son las soluciones que encontró Albert originalmente, simplemente se transportan:


A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
A augmented => ['A', 'C#', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A disminished => ['A', 'C', 'Eb'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
A major => ['A', 'C#', 'E'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
A minor => ['A', 'C', 'E'] Db major => ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
Ab augmented => ['Ab', 'C', 'E'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A']
Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb']
Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb']
Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab disminished => ['Ab', 'B', 'D'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] E disminished => ['E', 'G', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab major => ['Ab', 'C', 'Eb'] E minor => ['E', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] C major => ['C', 'E', 'G'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
Ab minor => ['Ab', 'B', 'D#'] Db disminished => ['Db', 'E', 'G'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
B augmented => ['B', 'D#', 'G'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
B disminished => ['B', 'D', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
B major => ['B', 'D#', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb']
B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb']
B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
B minor => ['B', 'D', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb major => ['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Bb augmented => ['Bb', 'D', 'F#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] F disminished => ['F', 'Ab', 'B']
Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] D disminished => ['D', 'F', 'Ab'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C']
Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Bb disminished => ['Bb', 'Db', 'E'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A'] F minor => ['F', 'Ab', 'C'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb disminished => ['Gb', 'A', 'C']
Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Bb major => ['Bb', 'D', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb minor => ['Gb', 'A', 'C#']
Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B']
Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] D major => ['D', 'F#', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
Bb minor => ['Bb', 'Db', 'F'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb disminished => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'A'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
C augmented => ['C', 'E', 'G#'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] G disminished => ['G', 'Bb', 'Db']
C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
C disminished => ['C', 'Eb', 'Gb'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G minor => ['G', 'Bb', 'D']
C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B']
C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
C minor => ['C', 'Eb', 'G'] E major => ['E', 'G#', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B']
D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C']
D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#']
D augmented => ['D', 'F#', 'A#'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#']
D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
D minor => ['D', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb major => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'Db']
Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
Db augmented => ['Db', 'F', 'A'] E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Eb augmented => ['Eb', 'G', 'B'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']
Db minor => ['Db', 'E', 'G#'] F major => ['F', 'A', 'C'] G augmented => ['G', 'B', 'D#'] Gb augmented => ['Gb', 'Bb', 'D']
E augmented => ['E', 'G#', 'C'] Eb minor => ['Eb', 'Gb', 'Bb'] F augmented => ['F', 'A', 'C#'] G major => ['G', 'B', 'D']

[fervili]

En este hilo no me atrevo ni a intentar hacer una broma.
Me dejáis con el culo pegao a la pared.

[albertus]

Pues me he escrito un programita que los calcula por mí. Ahí van unos cuantos ejemplos.

[+] Ejemplo1

[['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'], ['F', 'A', 'C#'], ['B', 'D', 'F#'], ['C', 'E', 'G#']]

[+] Ejemplo2

[['Gb', 'Bb', 'D'], ['C', 'E', 'G'], ['A', 'C#', 'F'], ['Ab', 'Cb', 'Eb']]

[+] Ejemplo3

[['E', 'G', 'Bb'], ['A', 'C', 'Eb'], ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'], ['B', 'D', 'F#']]

[+] Ejemplo4

[['C', 'E', 'G#'], ['D', 'F#', 'A'], ['B', 'D#', 'G'], ['Bb', 'Db', 'F']]

Por cierto, mi programa tiene un problema con las enarmonías (Por ejemplo, la tríada de Ab menor me la calcula como Lab, Si, Re#; siendo lo correcto Lab, Dob, Eb. En los ejemplos lo he corregido.

Por cierto, ¿en qué página mencionan el problema?
Nicolas_Slonimsky.pdf

tuampaaaa tuampaaaa

[albertus]

Pues me he escrito un programita que los calcula por mí. Ahí van unos cuantos ejemplos.

[+] Ejemplo1

[['Eb', 'G', 'Bb'], ['F', 'A', 'C#'], ['B', 'D', 'F#'], ['C', 'E', 'G#']]

[+] Ejemplo2

[['Gb', 'Bb', 'D'], ['C', 'E', 'G'], ['A', 'C#', 'F'], ['Ab', 'Cb', 'Eb']]

[+] Ejemplo3

[['E', 'G', 'Bb'], ['A', 'C', 'Eb'], ['Db', 'F', 'Ab'], ['B', 'D', 'F#']]

[+] Ejemplo4

[['C', 'E', 'G#'], ['D', 'F#', 'A'], ['B', 'D#', 'G'], ['Bb', 'Db', 'F']]

Por cierto, mi programa tiene un problema con las enarmonías (Por ejemplo, la tríada de Ab menor me la calcula como Lab, Si, Re#; siendo lo correcto Lab, Dob, Eb. En los ejemplos lo he corregido.

Por cierto, ¿en qué página mencionan el problema?
Nicolas_Slonimsky.pdf

los ejemplos tuyos 1,2 y 4 son iguales, tienes que hacer que el programa descarte los resultados "transportados" jejeje, aunque sigue siendo tuampa

el problema me lo inventé yo al leer que decía que es posible hacerlo con dos mayores y dos menores

[contrabajo]

Claro que es trampa

Pero sé hacerlo con lápiz y papel, que conste.

El reto para mí era instruir a un ordenador, que es tonto del culo, a calcularlo él. De hecho es tan tonto que si empieza a hacerlo todo basándose en tríadas de un mismo tipo se atasca y tiene que volver a empezar ya mezclando tipos diferentes de triadas, hasta que da con la solución. A ver si pienso algo para que sea capaz de hacerlo "con cabeza" en vez de ir probando combinaciones al buen tuntún

Me encantan estos retos, que mezclan dos de las cosas que más me gustan que es la armonía y la programación

De hecho, te agradezco que lo hayas planteado, porque me ha dado la idea para empezar un proyecto (informático) que tenía hacía mucho tiempo en mente pero no sabía muy bien cómo abordarlo.

[albertus]

Claro que es trampa

Pero sé hacerlo con lápiz y papel, que conste.

El reto para mí era instruir a un ordenador, que es tonto del culo, a calcularlo él. De hecho es tan tonto que si empieza a hacerlo todo basándose en tríadas de un mismo tipo se atasca y tiene que volver a empezar ya mezclando tipos diferentes de triadas, hasta que da con la solución. A ver si pienso algo para que sea capaz de hacerlo "con cabeza" en vez de ir probando combinaciones al buen tuntún

Me encantan estos retos, que mezclan dos de las cosas que más me gustan que es la armonía y la programación

De hecho, te agradezco que lo hayas planteado, porque me ha dado la idea para empezar un proyecto (informático) que tenía hacía mucho tiempo en mente pero no sabía muy bien cómo abordarlo.

yuhuu

[SUGATA]

[+] respuesta

la gallina

[ankbass]

[+] respuesta

la gallina

Discrepo!!!! no queda sino batirnos